Connect with us

KEO News Wire

Boks must stop trying to be the All Blacks

Published

on

Springboks

The Springboks have become so obsessed with evolving their attacking game that they are forgetting the rugby that made them world champions, according to Zelim Nel.

Speaking on the Keo & Zels Show, Nel delivered a scathing assessment of South Africa’s tactical approach following their 21-19 Nations Championship defeat to France.

While acknowledging the improvements made under attack coach Tony Brown, Nel believes the Springboks have sacrificed too much of their traditional identity in pursuit of a more expansive style.

“For me tactically, I just feel like the Boks have allowed the main thing not to be the main thing anymore,” Nel said.

The concern is not that South Africa are attacking too much, but that they are attacking without first establishing the pressure that makes their attacking players so dangerous.

Springboks have forgotten the winning formula

Nel highlighted the contrast between the kicking strategies employed by France and South Africa.

According to figures discussed on the show, France generated approximately 73% of their metres through kicking, while the Springboks were below 40%.

South Africa repeatedly launched contestable kicks but recovered only a small percentage of them, allowing France to win possession and relieve pressure through longer territorial kicks.

Nel questioned why an experienced Springbok side failed to adjust when the original plan clearly wasn’t working.

“We put the ball up five times. We won it back once. We need to adjust what we’re doing here,” he said, illustrating the conversation he believed should have taken place on the field.

Instead, the Springboks continued with an approach that was yielding increasingly poor returns.

For Nel, the failure to recognise and respond to that tactical imbalance was more concerning than the final score.

Springboks must learn to win as favourites

Attack must come after pressure

The Springboks have traditionally built their success on physical dominance, accurate kicking, aggressive defence and the ability to punish opposition mistakes.

Nel believes those elements must remain the foundation of South Africa’s game, regardless of how much attacking talent they possess.

“You can’t score counterattack tries if you’re not kicking. You can’t score turnover tries if you’re not defending,” he said.

The argument is not a rejection of attacking rugby.

South Africa have some of the most dangerous finishers in international rugby, and Brown’s influence has helped expand their attacking options.

But Nel warned that the pursuit of constant possession and attacking opportunities can become counterproductive when it comes at the expense of field position and defensive pressure.

“We used to be a team that puts pressure on other sides and then punishes them when they make mistakes,” he said.

“We’ve kind of tried to become New Zealand in the same way that New Zealand have tried to become Scotland in their attack. It’s not working.”

World Cup warning for Springboks

Nel pointed to New Zealand’s defeat against Wales as another example of a leading rugby nation getting its tactical priorities wrong.

Despite dominating possession, the All Blacks struggled against a Welsh side prepared to defend relentlessly and play a more pragmatic territorial game.

The similarities with South Africa’s defeat were difficult to ignore.

Nel believes both teams are capable of reverting to successful percentage rugby immediately after losing, but questioned why those lessons are repeatedly forgotten.

The Springboks remain back-to-back world champions and one of the most successful sides in international rugby.

However, Nel argued that their experience and quality should make them considerably more consistent in the biggest matches.

The challenge for Erasmus is not to abandon attacking innovation, but to restore the balance that made the Springboks so difficult to beat.

Because when the 2027 World Cup reaches the knockout stages, having the most talented players will mean little if South Africa cannot consistently make the right tactical decisions.

The Springboks don’t need to become another team. They need to remember what makes them the best version of themselves.


Trending

Copyright © 2025 Keo.co.za